2008-2009 Champions
St. John Fisher

2007-2008 Champions
St. John Fisher

2006-2007 Champions
St. John Fisher

2005 Champions
St. John Fisher

2004 Champions
St. John Fisher

2003 Champions
Nazareth College

2002 Champions
Nazareth College

2001 Champions
St. John Fisher

2000 Champions
St. John Fisher