| Year |
Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coaching Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2024-25 |
Jaylen Savage, Nazareth |
Avery Oduro-Dompreh, Russell Sage |
Merritt Holly, Nazareth |
Joe Clarke, SUNY Brockport |
Damien Call, Utica |
| 2023-24 |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
Henry Perkins, Hartwick |
Sean Coffey, Utica |
Justice Brantley, Utica |
| 2022-23 |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
Jonathan Park, Nazareth |
Jaylen Savage, Nazareth |
Sean Coffey, Utica |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
| 2021-22 |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
Darius Hopkins, Utica |
Bryan Adams, Elmira |
Sean Coffey, Utica |
Stephen Gabel, Nazareth |
| 2020-21 |
Daniel Cook, St. John Fisher |
Sean Williams, St. John Fisher |
Damien Call, Utica |
Mike Grosodonia, St. John Fisher |
Kimedrick Murphy, Utica |
| 2019-20 |
Sammy Robinson, St. John Fisher |
Zach Stenglein, Nazareth |
Thomas Morreale, Utica |
Kevin Broderick, Nazareth |
Dennis Hare, St. John Fisher |
| 2018-19 |
Ryan Henderson, St. John Fisher |
Sage Brown, Alfred |
Elliott Bowen, Alfred |
Russ Phillips, Alfred |
Dom LeMorta, Alfred |
| 2017-18 |
Tyler Stenglein, Nazareth |
Ivan Iton, Utica |
Kevin Townes, Hartwick |
Kevin Broderick, Nazareth |
Tyler Stenglein, Nazareth |
|
Offensive Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coaching Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2016-17 |
Keegan Ryan, St. John Fisher |
Ivan Iton, Utica College |
Spencer Cook, Stevens |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher College |
Tyler English, St. John Fisher |
|
Player of the Year |
|
Rookie of the Year |
Coach/Coaching Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2015-16 |
Mitch Ford, Nazareth |
|
Tyler Stenglein, Nazareth |
Kevin Broderick, Nazareth
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher College |
Jake Sinicki, Hartwick |
| 2014-15 |
Keegan Ryan, St. John Fisher |
|
Marc Chasin, Ithaca |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
Stefan Bock, St. John Fisher |
| 2013-14 |
Jared Suderley, Hartwick |
|
Joey Lufkin, Hartwick |
Dale Wellman, Alfred |
Jared Suderley, Hartwick |
| 2012-13 |
Sheldon Jones, Stevens |
|
Chaz Lott, St. John Fisher |
Bobby Hurley, Stevens |
Frank Mitchell, Ithaca |
| 11-12 |
Jared Suderley, Hartwick |
|
Aaron Nevins, Utica |
Todd McGuinness, Hartwick |
Sean Rossi, Ithaca |
| 10-11 |
Phil Barera, Ithaca |
|
Jared Suderley, Hartwick |
Bobby Hurley, Stevens |
|
| 09-10 |
Corey McAdams, Nazareth |
|
Sean Rossi, Ithaca |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 08-09 |
Sean Burton, Ithaca |
|
Mark Blazek, Hartwick |
Jim Mullins, Ithaca |
|
| 07-08 |
Sean Burton, Ithaca |
|
Shane Foster, RIT
Ozell Franklin, St. John Fisher |
Jim Mullins, Ithaca |
|
| 06-07 |
Ray Bryant, Utica |
|
Corey McAdams, Nazareth |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 05-06 |
Sean O'Brien, St. John Fisher |
|
Jay Cocozziello, Hartwick |
Andy Goodemote, Utica
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 04-05 |
Jeff Sidney, St. John Fisher |
|
Joe Canori, Nazareth |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 03-04 |
Tyler Schultz, Nazareth |
|
Dillon Stein, Alfred |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 02-03 |
Jim Evans, Nazareth |
|
Fran Snyder, RIT |
Rob Kornaker, St. John Fisher |
|
| 01-02 |
Brandon Redmond, RIT |
|
Jeff Sidney, St. John Fisher |
Jim Mullins, Ithaca |
|
| 00-01 |
Devon Downing, Alfred
Brandon Redmont, RIT |
|
Jay Orr, Hartwick |
Jay Murphy, Alfred |
|
| 99-00 |
Pat Britton, Ithaca |
|
Dewaun Cheathan, Utica |
Bob McVean, RIT |
|