| Year |
Player of the Year |
Pitcher of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coaching Staff/Coach of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2025 |
Zach Eldred, Brockport |
Anthony Lapine, Brockport |
Jacob Mansell, Brockport |
Jordan Perry, St. John Fisher |
Brockport |
Anthony Lapine, Brockport |
| 2024 |
Brendan Espinal, Russell Sage |
Ethan Cetton, Houghton |
James Murphy, St. John Fisher |
Jacob Scalise, Utica |
Russell Sage |
James Murphy, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Noah Campanelli, St. John Fisher |
Patrick McGuire, St. John Fisher |
Jared Money, Elmira |
Kooper Knabe, Utica |
St. John Fisher |
Ethan Perry, St. John Fisher |
| 2022 |
Noah Campanelli, St. John Fisher |
Connor McHugh, St. John Fisher |
|
Brett Warden, Elmira |
St. John Fisher |
Michael Beimel, St. John Fisher |
| 2021 |
Adam Zebrowski, St. John Fisher |
R.J. Kuruts, St. John Fisher |
|
James Ward, Jr., St. John Fisher |
Houghton College |
Justin Graham, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
Allen Murphy, St. John Fisher |
Emmett Dunn, Ithaca |
|
Kenneth Westbrook, St. John Fisher |
Ithaca College |
Adam Gallagher, Ithaca |
| 2018 |
Alex Detweiler, Stevens |
Charlier Ruegger, Stevens |
|
Thomas Paulich, Stevens |
Stevens |
Sam Little, Ithaca |
| 2017 |
Scott Eisenmenger, St. John Fisher |
Anthony Brophy, St. John Fisher |
|
Anthony Brophy, St. John Fisher |
Elmira College |
Ryan Henchey, Ithaca |
| 2016 |
Jayson Yano, Stevens |
Jayson Yano, Stevens |
|
Sam Little, Ithaca |
St. John Fisher |
John Prendergast, Ithaca |
| 2015 |
Jayson Yano, Stevens |
Jayson Yano, Stevens |
|
Scott Eisenmenger, St. John Fisher |
Stevens |
*Christian Brown, Ithaca |
| 2014 |
Nick Flemister, St. John Fisher |
John Prendergast, Ithaca |
|
Marc Iseneker, St. John Fisher |
Ithaca College |
|
| 2013 |
Tim Locastro, Ithaca |
Pat Lemmo, Ithaca |
|
Matt Connolly, Ithaca
Jayson Yano, Stevens |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2012 |
Steve Karnyski, St. John Fisher |
Justin D'Amato, St. John Fisher
Pat Lemmo, Ithaca |
|
John Prendergast, Ithaca |
George Valesenta, Ithaca
Kristaps Aldins, Stevens |
|
| 2011 |
Steve Karnyski, St. John Fisher |
Justin D'Amato, St. John Fisher |
|
Justin D'Amato, St. John Fisher |
Brandon Potter, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2010 |
Geoff Dornes, RIT |
Dan Jurik, St. John Fisher |
|
Ben Bostick, St. John Fisher |
Brandon Potter, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2009 |
Leo Fusilli, St. John Fisher |
Pete MacDaniel, Ithaca |
|
Teagan Barresi, St. John Fisher |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2008 |
Geoff Dornes, RIT |
Bryan Gardner, Ithaca |
|
David Ahonen, Ithaca |
Rob Grow, RIT
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2007 |
Geoff Dornes, RIT |
Dylan Rees, RIT |
|
Geoff Dornes, RIT |
Dan Pepicelli, St. John Fisher |
|
|
Player of the Year |
|
Rookie |
Coach |
|
| 2006 |
Andy Campbell, St. John Fisher |
|
Drew Ash, Ithaca |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2005 |
Andy Campbell, St. John Fisher |
|
Rob Raux, Ithaca |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2004 |
Andy Campbell, St. John Fisher |
|
Chris Botsford, St. John Fisher |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2003 |
Kyle Williams, Ithaca |
|
Andy Campbell, St. John Fisher |
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2002 |
Geoff Osbourne, St. John Fisher |
|
Nick Bergman, St. John Fisher |
Barry Shelton, Hartwick
George Valesente, Ithaca |
|
| 2001 |
Scott Allen, Ithaca |
|
Patrick Craig, St. John Fisher |
Dan Pepicelli, St. John Fisher |
|