| Year |
Offensive Player |
Defensive Player |
Special Teams Player |
Rookie |
Coach/Coaching Staff |
| 2024 |
Zac Boyes, Cortland |
Nick Lardaro, Cortland |
Mike Baloga, Cortland |
Conor Cosgrove, Hartwick |
Curt Fitzpatrick, Cortland |
| 2023 |
Zac Boyes, Cortland |
Raylens Boutin, Brockport |
Patrick Luby, Cortland |
Sam Cotton, Cortland |
Curt Fitzpatrick, Cortland |
| 2022 |
Nate Palmer, Utica |
Ernesto Mitchell, Morrisville (co)
Jimmie Warren, Utica (co) |
Patrick Luby, Cortland |
Malik Kelly, Brockport |
Curt Fitzpatrick, Cortland |
| 2021 |
Brees Segala, Cortland |
Dylan Dubuque, Cortland |
Tysean Sizer, St. John Fisher |
Nick Lardaro, Cortland |
Curt Fitzpatrick, Cortland |
| 2019 |
Bill Flatow, Morrisville |
Raeqwon Greer, Alfred |
Maki Medici, Utica |
Raylens Boutin, Brockport |
Jason Mangone, Brockport |
| 2018 |
Joe Germinerio, Brockport |
Austin Dean, Brockport |
Nick Mongelli, Cortland |
Logan Wilcox, Utica |
Jason Mangone, Brockport |
| 2017 |
Joe Germinerio, Brockport |
A.J. LiCata, Alfred |
Trevor Monk, Alfred
Brett Renzi, Brockport |
Tyree Brown, Brockport |
Jason Mangone, Brockport |
| 2016 |
Tyler Johnson, Alfred |
A.J. LiCata, Alfred |
Jordan Schemm, Ithaca |
Joe Germinerio, Brockport |
Rob Rankl, Alfred |
| 2015 |
Dan Andrews, Brockport |
Tarik Bennett, Brockport |
Thomas Woodburn, Utica |
Donny Davis, Cortland |
Dan MacNeill, Cortland |
| 2014 |
Tyler Fenti, St. John Fisher |
Marquis Artis, Buffalo State |
Kyle Hamby, Salisbury |
Kenneth Bradley, Ithaca |
Mike Welch, Ithaca |
| 2013 |
Tyler Fenti, St. John Fisher
Anthony Acevedo, Utica |
Andre Carter, Salisbury |
Kyle Hamby, Salisbury |
Tyler Johnson, Alfred |
Mike Welch, Ithaca |
| 2012 |
Andrew Benkwitt, Utica |
Mike Raplee, Alfred |
Kyle Hamby, Salisbury |
Maleke Fuentes, Alfred |
Sherman Wood, Salisbury |
| 2011 |
Dan Griffin, Salisbury |
Nick Clark, Alfred |
Dan Ruffrage, Ithaca |
J.D. Hook, Frostburg |
Sherman Wood, Salisbury |
| 2010** |
Tim Bailey, St. John Fisher |
Nick Clark, Alfred |
Andrew Rogowski, Ithaca |
Austin Dwyer, Alfred |
Dave Murray, Alfred |
| 2009 |
Jared Manzer, Alfred |
Andy Episcopo, St. John Fisher |
|
Andrew Benkwitt, Utica |
Dave Murray, Alfred |
| 2008 |
Jason Boltus, Hartwick |
Matt Scalice, Ithaca |
|
Tom Secky, Alfred |
Mike Welch, Ithaca |
| 2007 |
Jason Boltus, Hartwick |
Steve Stepnick, St. John Fisher |
|
Jason Springer, Norwich |
Mark Carr, Hartwick |
| 2006* |
Chris Sharpe, Springfield |
Gene Lang, St. John Fisher |
|
Jared Manzer, Alfred |
Mike DeLong, Springfield |
| 2005 |
Josh Felicetti, Ithaca |
|
|
Jason Boltus, Hartwick |
Dave Murray, Alfred |
| 2004 |
Brenton Brady, Alfred |
|
|
Jamie Donocan, Ithaca |
Paul Vosburgh, St. John Fisher |
| 2003 |
Jesse Raynor, Alfred |
|
|
Aaron Meyers, Alfred |
Mike Welch, Ithaca |
| 2002 |
Dan Pincelli, Hartwick |
|
|
Josh Felicetti, Ithaca |
Paul Vosburgh, St. John Fisher |