| Year |
Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Goalkeeper of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach/Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2024 |
Katrina Clare, SUNY Geneseo |
Hailey Roethel, SUNY Geneseo |
Ella Buchanan, SUNY Brockport |
Michaela Cushman, Nazareth |
Margaret McConnell, SUNY Geneseo |
Sam Lewis, SUNY Geneseo |
| 2023 |
Julie Ruzzi, Hartwick
Amy Stevens, Russell Sage |
Madison Ranalli, Utica |
Sophia Trozzi, St. John Fisher |
Danielle Hand, Hartwick |
Lauren Scorza, St. John Fisher |
Julie Ruzzi, Hartwick |
| 2022 |
Sydney Gagnon, Hartwick |
Libby Fortin, Hartwick |
Madison Maddocks, Hartwick |
Lily Giering, W&J |
Erin Autera, Hartwick |
Leah Tolley, Hartwick |
| 2021 |
Bre Socker, SJFC |
Selena Emery, SJFC |
Amanda Chuttey, Nazareth |
Jace Hunzinger, Houghton |
Erin Autera, Hartwick |
Bre Socker, SJFC |
| 2020-21* |
Bre Socker, SJFC |
Hannah Daniels, Houghton |
Allyson Osborne, Hartwick |
Emily Strutt, Hartwick |
Tori Bothner, St. John Fisher |
Bre Socker, SJFC |
| 2019 |
Lindsay Scott, SJFC |
|
|
Sydney Gagnon, Hartwick |
Tori Bothner, St. John Fisher |
Brooke Singer, Hartwick |
| 2018 |
Rachel Buyan, W&J |
|
|
Emily Franco, Stevens |
Washington & Jefferson |
Rachel Buyan, W&J |
| 2017 |
Emily Markarian, SJFC |
|
|
Bre Socker, SJFC |
Washington & Jefferson |
Rachel Buyan, W&J |
| 2016 |
Emily Markarian, SJFC |
|
|
Lindsay Scott, SJFC
Maria Stalder, Hartwick |
Tori Bothner, St. John Fisher |
Emily Markarian, SJFC |
| 2015 |
Katie Lass, Ithaca |
|
|
Alana Boyd, W&J |
Ithaca College |
Dailyn Brook, Stevens |
| 2014 |
Hannah Mackey, Utica |
|
|
Emily Markarian, St. John Fisher |
Utica College |
Amanda Vitro, Utica |
| 2013 |
Marguerite Chavez, Stevens |
|
|
Katie Lass, Ithaca |
Emily Beach, Stevens |
Hannah Mackey, Utica |
| 2012 |
Louise Steele-Norton, Utica |
|
|
Katie Lonsky, Hartwick |
Tarah Christenson, St. John Fisher |
Alaina Stojkovski, Utica |
| 2011 |
Mallory Swanson, Stevens |
|
|
Hannah Mackey, Utica |
Sarah Elleman, Utica |
Meghan Thornlow, W&J |
| 2010 |
Jennifer Marabella, W&J |
|
|
Alex Kania, W&J |
Jomara Coghlan, W&J |
Ellyn Griggs, Stevens |
| 2009 |
Kara Borzillo, Stevens |
|
|
Kelsey Kimble, Hartwick |
Anna Meyer, Hartwick |
|
| 2008 |
Allison Sheilds, Stevens |
|
|
Rebecca Corsones, Utica |
Jessica Reed, Stevens |
|
| 2007 |
Kelly Miransa, Nazareth |
|
|
Laruen Griggs, Stevens |
Jomara Coghlan, W&J |
|
| 2006 |
Katie Kutas, Utica |
|
|
Courtney Geddes, Stevens |
Jessica Reed, Stevens |
|
| 2005 |
Tasha Snowden, Ithaca |
|
|
Katie Kutas, Utica |
Megan McGuin, Utica |
|
| 2004 |
Kelly Cooman, Hartwick |
|
|
Danielle Fiore, Utica |
Anna Meyer, Hartwick |
|
| 2003 |
Tara Wilkes, Hartwick |
|
|
Riana Bovill, Elmira |
Bern Macca, Elmira
Pat Mihalko, Utica |
|
| 2002 |
Tara Wilkes, Hartwick |
|
|
Tasha Snowden, Ithaca |
Bern Macca, Elmira |
|