| Year |
Offensive Player |
Defensive Player |
Goalkeeper |
Rookie |
Coach |
Tournament MVP |
| 2025 |
Quinn McKercher, Nazareth |
Jack Cornell, St. John Fisher |
Tyler Manning, St. John Fisher |
JP Revitte, St. John Fisher |
Dave Dobbins, St. John Fisher |
Brady Mason, St. John Fisher |
| 2024 |
Matthew Kemmis, St. John Fisher |
Jack Cornell, St. John Fisher |
McLean Ralston, Nazareth |
Sean Donaldson, St. John Fisher |
Dave Dobbins, St. John Fisher |
Ben Hammond, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Quinn McKercher, Nazareth |
Brian Jantz, St. John Fisher |
Scott Kimiecik, Alfred |
Matthew Farrington, Nazareth |
Jason Lockner, Alfred |
Jacob Gallina, St. John Fisher |
| Year |
Player |
|
Goalkeeper |
Rookie |
Coach |
Tournament MVP |
| 2022 |
Joe Post, St. John Fisher |
|
Scott Kimiecik, Alfred |
Matt Keane, Nazareth |
Dave Dobbins, St. John Fisher |
Ben Hammond, St. John Fisher |
| 2021 |
Ian Evans, St. John Fisher |
|
Darin Eakins, St. John Fisher |
Quinn McKercher, Nazareth |
Dave Dobbins, St. John Fisher |
Nicholas Miller, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
Max Bailey, Stevens |
|
Carson White, Stevens |
Ian Evans, St. John Fisher |
Gene Peluso, Stevens |
Darin Eakins, St. John Fisher |
| 2018 |
Max Bailey, Stevens |
|
Carson White, Stevens |
Ryan Gebhardt, Stevens |
Gene Peluso, Stevens |
John Boutureira, Stevens |
| 2017 |
Seth DeLisle, Nazareth |
|
Jack Deragon, Ithaca |
Alex Winkler, Nazareth |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
Joe Eiskant, Nazareth |
| 2016 |
Eli Gobrecht, Ithaca |
|
Scott Sidnam, Ithaca |
Max Bailey, Stevens |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
Scott Sidnam, Ithaca |
| 2015 |
Drew Simoneau, Nazareth |
|
Scott Sidnam, Ithaca |
Jake Lynch, Alfred |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
Will Fallo, Nazareth |
| 2014 |
Drew Simoneau, Nazareth |
|
Jamie Campagna, St. John Insert Row BeforeFisher |
John Januszkiewicz, Ithaca |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
Scott Sidnam, Ithaca |
| 2013 |
Drew Simoneau, Nazareth |
|
Scott Sidnam, Ithaca |
Luke Wooters, Nazareth |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
Luke Wooters, Nazareth |
| 2012 |
Rich Dupras, Stevens |
|
Brendan Green, Ithaca |
Drew Simoneau, Nazareth |
Gene Peluso, Stevens |
Matt Marks, Stevens |
| 2011 |
MJ Kiekebelt, RIT |
|
David Gal, Ithaca |
Christian Saley, Stevens |
Jake Coon, RIT |
Jordan MacIntosh, RIT |
| 2010 |
Narj DeCirce, Nazareth
Jordan MacIntosh, RIT |
|
Dave Decker, Stevens |
Harry Hughes, Hartwick |
Jake Coon, RIT |
|
| 2009 |
Matt Keating, Stevens |
|
Dave Decker, Stevens |
C.J. Estes, Nazareth |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
|
| 2008 |
Matt Nelligan, Ithaca |
|
Dave Decker, Stevens |
Vito DeMola, Hartwick |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
|
| 2007 |
Ryan Hotaling, Nazareth |
|
Dennis Butler, Ithaca |
Erinn O'Hara, Nazareth |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
|
| 2006 |
David Thering, RIT |
|
|
Mike Cintineo, Ithaca |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
|
| 2005 |
Matt Casey, Ithaca |
|
|
Andrew Ruocco, RIT |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
|
| 2004 |
Josh Molinari, RIT |
|
|
Dennis Butler, Ithaca
Andy German, Alfred |
Gene Peluso, RIT |
|
| 2003 |
Matt Kent, Nazareth |
|
|
David Thering, RIT |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
|
| 2002 |
Ryan Martin, Ithaca |
|
|
Brian Weil, Ithaca |
Jeff Long, Ithaca |
|
| 2001 |
Eric Goodberlet, Nazareth |
|
|
Mark Colite, Hartwick |
Rob Randall, Nazareth |
|