| Year |
Offensive Player of the Year ^ |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Goalkeeper of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Doug May Coach of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2024 |
Joey Avallone, St. John Fisher |
Joe Vogt, SUNY Geneseo |
Christian Burkhart, St. John Fisher |
Hunter Bulich, Hartwick |
Jack Burgasser, St. John Fisher |
Christian Burkhart, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Martin Harguindey, Elmira |
|
Dante Gesamondo, Hartwick |
Gavin Culley, Alfred |
Lamine Balde, Elmira |
Jhoan Chavez, Elmira |
| 2022 |
Ander Castillo, Medaille |
|
Carson Smith, Keuka |
Kwame Amissah-Arthur, Hartwick |
Jack Burgasser, St. John Fisher |
Eric Metade, Medaille |
| 2021 |
Sory Konate, Utica |
|
Logan Menna, Nazareth |
Riley Rease, St. John Fisher |
Matt Tantalo, Nazareth |
Drew Decker, Nazareth |
| 2020-21* |
Justin Bonetto, St. John Fisher |
|
Caleb Loew, Houghton
Jadon Schlierf, St. John Fisher |
Cooper LaValley, Nazareth |
Jack Burgasser, St. John Fisher |
Matt Gentile, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
Jake Adams, Nazareth |
|
|
Justin Eaton, Alfred |
Matt Tantalo, Nazareth |
Dereck France, Nazareth |
| 2018 |
Daniel Aversano, Stevens |
|
|
Adam Silva, Stevens |
Dale Jordan, Stevens |
Chris Cesario, Stevens |
| 2017 |
River Seybolt, Sage |
|
|
Josh Crespo, Nazareth |
Matt Tantalo, Nazareth |
Nicholas Cousillas, Stevens |
| 2016 |
Michael Bryant, Elmira |
|
|
Daniel Aversano, Stevens |
Dale Jordan, Stevens |
Matthew Kaiser, St. John Fisher |
| 2015 |
Colin Phillips, Stevens |
|
|
Andrew Bussey, Houghton |
Patrick Ouckama, Ithaca |
Carson Pryor, Stevens |
| 2014 |
Harrison Kane, Stevens |
|
|
Bita Gazashvill, Utica |
Matt Smith, Alfred |
Mike Renna, Stevens |
| 2013 |
Carson Pryor, Stevens |
|
|
Jacob Dunnet, Houghton |
Devin Rensing, Stevens |
Joe Cellitti, Stevens |
| 2012 |
Victor Daza, Stevens |
|
|
Wendell Ming, Elmira |
Rob Searl, St. John FIsher |
Paul Killian, Stevens |
| 2011 |
Zach Adler, Stevens |
|
|
Andre Germano, Elmira |
Devin Rensing, Stevens |
Zach Adler, Stevens |
| 2010 |
Nolan Sandberg, Stevens |
|
|
Ryan Foley, Nazareth |
Tim O'Donohue, Stevens |
|
| 2009 |
Nolan Sandberg, Stevens |
|
|
Alex Manchev, Nazareth |
Jeremiah Kneeland, Elmira |
|
| 2008 |
Terrance Johnson, Stevens |
|
|
Andy Alaimo, Nazareth |
Andy Byrne, Ithaca |
|
| 2007 |
Luke Lennox, St. John Fisher |
|
|
Andrew McIntosh, St. John Fisher |
Steve Christenson, Utica |
|
| 2006 |
Offensive - Kurt Odenbach, Ithaca
Defensive - Mohammed Ahamed, Nazareth |
|
|
Brian Haschke, Elmira |
Bill Garno, RIT |
|
| 2005 |
Mike Lawson, RIT |
|
|
Chris Somers, RIT
Eric Ferguson, Ithaca |
Andy Byrne, Ithaca |
|
| 2004 |
Mike Lawson, RIT |
|
|
Adam Blanchard, St. John FIsher |
Andy Byrne, Ithaca |
|
| 2003 |
Jefferson Dargout, Nazareth |
|
|
Bobby Linaberry, Alfred |
Ken Hassler, Alfred |
|
| 2002 |
Brian Lenzo, RIT |
|
|
Mike Lawson, RIT |
Andy Byrne, Ithaca |
|
| 2001 |
Cody Ostrum, RIT |
|
|
Ben Visnyei, Ithaca |
Ken Hassler, Alfred |
|
| 2000 |
Steve Fisher, Nazareth |
|
|
Trae Lower, RIT |
Bill Garno, RIT |
|