| Year |
Player of the Year |
Pitcher of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2025 |
Emily McManus, St. John Fisher |
Ainsley Evanetski, St. John Fisher |
Jessica Remm, Alfred |
Kaijah Alexander, Nazareth |
Bari Mance, St. John Fisher |
Kendall Steward, Alfred |
| 2024 |
Maddie Donlin, St. John Fisher |
Cassidy Ormond, St. John Fisher |
Mya Wells, Alfred |
Jennifer Rodriguez, Utica |
Bari Mance, St. John Fisher |
Mari Spitz, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Arianna Papas, Russell Sage |
Arden Hatch, Alfred |
Ashley Lugo, Alfred |
Jessica Remm, Alfred |
Luke Wesneski, Alfred |
Allie Klonowski, St. John Fisher |
| 2022 |
Allie Klonowski, St. John Fisher
Arianna Papas, Russell Sage |
Emily Daciw, Nazareth |
|
Meghan Neto, Alfred |
Chad Muise, Houghton |
Megan Bennett, Alfred |
| 2021 |
Emily Trotman, St. John Fisher |
Jessica Wilcox, Alfred |
|
Mya Wells, Alfred |
Bari Mance, St. John Fisher |
Jessica Wilcox, Alfred |
| 2019 |
Samantha Schattin, Stevens |
Marissa Cappello, Stevens |
|
Meg Halloran, Stevens |
Emily Kaczmarek, Stevens |
Ashley Prince, St. John Fisher |
| 2018 |
Sarah Kubik, St. John Fisher
Nicole Rice, Utica |
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
|
Sammie Torlish, St. John Fisher |
Bari Mance, St. John Fisher |
Sarah Kubik, St. John Fisher |
| 2017 |
Katie Mazierski, St. John Fisher |
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
|
Shannon Grage, Ithaca |
Jack Carpenter, Nazareth |
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
| 2016 |
Kelly Robichaud, Ithaca |
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
|
Vanessa Brown, Ithaca |
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
Kelly Robichaud, Ithaca |
| 2015 |
Liz Thompson, Alfred |
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
|
Lindsey Thayer, St. John Fisher |
Gino Olivieri, Alfred |
Kerri Keeler, Alfred |
| 2014 |
Sydney Folk, Ithaca |
Kayla Berardi, Stevens |
|
Jessica Rees, Stevens |
Erica Mehalick, Stevens |
Sam Bender, Ithaca |
| 2013 |
Chelsea Monroe, Utica |
Sarah Stefanon, St. John Fisher |
|
Alyssa Russell, Utica |
Pat Mineo, Utica |
Sarah Stefanon, St. John Fisher |
| 2012 |
Sydney Folk, Ithaca |
Jillian Olmstead, Ithaca
Danielle Leone, St. John Fisher |
|
Katie Dore, Elmira
Francesca Busa, Ithaca |
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
Julianne Vincent, Ithaca |
| 2011 |
Jennifer Vanek, St. John Fisher |
Brittany Kemp, RIT |
|
Kristie Jones, Utica |
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
|
| 2010 |
Nicole Hedrick, Alfred |
Kelly Kocher, Nazaret |
|
Emily Fenton, Alfred |
Gino Olivieri, Alfred |
|
| 2009 |
Karen Folts, Alfred
Brittanie Lillie, Ithaca |
Amanda Shevchuck, St. John Fisher |
|
Ann Marie Forenza, Ithaca |
Len Maiorani, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2008 |
Erica Cutspec, Ithaca
Sara Dresser, St. John Fisher |
Carly Myers, Ithaca |
|
Emily McPherson, RIT |
Gino Olivieri, Alfred |
|
| 2007 |
Hannah Shalett, Ithaca |
Nichole Cade, Ithaca |
|
Sara Gates, St. John Fisher |
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
|
|
Player of the Year |
|
Rookie |
Coach |
|
| 2006 |
Kaitlyn Dulac, Ithaca |
|
Ashley McBride Krause, St. John Fisher |
Pat Mineo, Utica |
|
| 2005 |
Leigh Bonkowski, Ithaca |
|
Carly Meyers, Ithaca |
Jack Carpenter, RIT |
|
| 2004 |
Zahida Sherman, Ithaca |
|
Zahida Sherman, Ithaca |
Len Maiorani, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2003 |
Shari McNamara, RIT |
|
Leigh Bonkowski, Ithaca |
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
|
| 2002 |
Shari McNamara, RIT |
|
Abby Pelot, Ithaca |
Jack Carpenter, RIT
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
|
| 2001 |
Laura Remia, Ithaca |
|
Shari McNamara, RIT |
Jack Carpenter, RIT
Deb Pallozzi, Ithaca |
|