| Year |
Player |
Rookie |
Coach |
| 2018 |
Danielle Bambola, Cortland |
|
|
| 2017 |
Tiffany Schapira, Cortland |
Hannah Fitzgerald, Cortland |
Joe Testori, Cortland |
| 2016 |
Kimberley Wong, Ithaca |
Peyton Greco, Ithaca |
Molly Braid, Ithaca |
| 2015 |
Indiana Jones, Ithaca |
Taylor Laughinghouse, SJFC |
Molly Braid, Ithaca |
| 2014 |
Sharon Li, Ithaca |
Kyra Denish, Ithaca |
Dan Wood, Ithaca |
| 2013 |
Sharon Li, Ithaca |
Kimberly Wong, Ithaca |
Dan Wood, Ithaca |
| 2012 |
Sharon Li, Ithaca |
Kelley Citrin, Nazareth |
Dan Wood, Ithaca |
| 2011 |
Alex Battle, St. John Fisher |
Sharon Li, Ithaca |
Dan Wood, Ithaca |
| 2010 |
Alex Battle, St. John Fisher |
Amanda Failla, Ithaca |
Dan Wood, Ithaca |
| 2009-10 |
Michelle Van Slyke, Nazareth |
Jackie Young, Ithaca |
|