| Year |
Player (Offensive Player) |
Midfielder of the Year (New for 2025) |
Defensive Player |
Goalkeeper |
Rookie |
Coach/Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2025 |
Hanna Kumpf, St. John Fisher |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
Maddie Lowney, St. John Fisher |
Kaylee Gadot, St. John Fisher
Allie Klestinec, Nazareth |
Karaline McCarthy, SUNY Brockport |
St. John Fisher |
Kaley Griffin, St. John Fisher |
| 2024 |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
|
Maddie Lowney, St. John Fisher |
Alyssa Piechota, Alfred |
Maria Stuhlman, Utica |
St. John Fisher |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Emma States, Nazareth |
|
Shannon Foster, St. John Fisher |
Lily Goodsell, St. John Fisher |
Maddie Lowney, St. John Fisher |
St. John Fisher |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
| 2022 |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
|
Emma Parry, Nazareth |
Claire Frier, Utica |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher
Amelia Booth, Alfred |
St. John Fisher
Nazareth |
Sydney Carpenter, St. John Fisher |
| 2021 |
Sydney DeGirolamo, St. John Fisher |
|
Victoria Arena, Nazareth |
Katie Lawrence, Nazareth |
Shannon Foster, St. John Fisher
Eleanor Matz, Nazareth |
St. John Fisher |
Sydney DeGirolamo, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
Kyra Bednarski, Stevens |
|
Molly Tice, St. John Fisher |
Ashley Jablonowski, Hartwick |
Sydney DeGirolamo, St. John Fisher |
Utica |
Mary Grace Doyle, St. John Fisher |
| 2018 |
Kyra Bednarksi, Stevens |
|
|
Brianna Rizzari, Nazareth |
Stephany Husnay, Utica |
Stevens |
Claire Bollin, St. John Fisher |
| 2017 |
Ally Runyon, Ithaca |
|
|
Kimberly Presuto, Ithaca |
Kyra Bednarski, Stevens |
Stevens |
Claire Bollin, St. John Fisher |
| 2016 |
Erika Wilcox, Stevens |
|
|
Kimberly Presuto, Ithaca |
Allison Panara, Ithaca |
Ithaca College |
Haley Peets, St. John Fisher |
| 2015 |
Erika Wilcox, Stevens |
|
|
Ashley Kirch, Nazareth |
Haley DeVona, Nazareth |
Nazareth College |
Lindsey Shoales, St. John Fisher |
| 2014 |
Taylor Hughes, St. John Fisher |
|
|
Tara Prosak, Nazareth |
Kathleen Kalbian, Stevens |
Ithaca College |
Nicole Hart, St. John Fisher |
| 2013 |
Tracy Rivas, Ithaca |
|
|
Tara Prosak, Nazareth |
Allison Runyon, Ithaca |
Ithaca College |
Melissa Leonhard, St. John Fisher |
| 2012 |
Tracy Rivas, Ithaca |
|
|
Jess Worthman, Ithaca |
Amanda Ingersoll, Stevens |
Shannon McHale, Ithaca |
Taylor Hughes, St. John Fisher |
| 2011 |
Shelby Vakiener, RIT |
|
|
Shelby Barbay, Utica |
Taylor Hughes, St. John Fisher |
Celine Cunningham,Stevens |
|
| 2010 |
Alyssa Pigott, Stevens |
|
|
Shelby Barbay, Utica |
Shelby Vakiener, RIT |
Karen Hollands, Ithaca |
|
| 2009 |
Alyssa Pigott, Stevens |
|
|
Kelsey Evans, RIT |
Lindsay Mitchell, Elmira |
Celine Cunningham, Stevens |
|
| 2008 |
Laurie Quackenbush, St. John Fisher |
|
|
Kelsey Evans, RIT |
Tammy Kohanski, Utica |
Sue Behme, Nazareth |
|
| 2007 |
Laurie Quackenbush, St. John Fisher |
|
|
Kelsey Evans, RIT |
Lauren Glavin, St. John Fisher |
Shannon McHale, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2006 |
Betsy Carney, Nazareth |
|
|
|
Jen Springett, St. John Fisher |
Sue Behme, Nazareth |
|
| 2005 |
Katya Outwater, Elmira |
|
|
|
Meagan Howell, Ithaca |
Sue Behme, Nazareth |
|
| 2004 |
Michelle Schlegel, Ithaca |
|
|
|
Theresa Nobilski, St. John Fisher |
Karen Hollands, Ithaca |
|
| 2003 |
Shawna Kabot, Nazareth
Jessica Welch, Ithaca |
|
|
|
Kurstin Meehan, Ithaca |
Karen Hollands, Ithaca |
|
| 2002 |
Allison Roberts, Nazareth |
|
|
|
Lindsay Gotham, Nazareth |
Sue Behme, Nazareth |
|
| 2001 |
Brooke Andrews, Ithaca |
|
|
|
Michelle Schlegel, Ithaca |
Piep van Heuven, Ithaca |
|