| Year |
Player of the Year |
Libero/Defensive Specialist |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach/Staff of the Year |
Tournament MVP |
| 2024 |
Tessa Grover, Nazareth |
Elsie Logan, SUNY Brockport |
Lydia Fraser, St. John Fisher |
Tara Jehlen, Nazareth |
Ana Gutman, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Kaylene Noble, St. John Fisher |
Kiera Hartpence, St. John Fisher |
Kaylene Noble, St. John Fisher |
Kelly Greapentrog, St. John Fisher |
Casey Grange, Alfred |
| 2022 |
Braelyn Hornick, Hartwick |
Elaina Moisidis, Russell Sage |
Casey Grange, Alfred |
Jim Clar, Hartwick |
Kiana Walker, St. John Fisher |
| 2021 |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
Darian Ortiz, Alfred |
Tessa Grover, Nazareth |
Kelly Greapentrog, St. John Fisher |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
| 2020-21 * |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
Darian Ortiz, Alfred |
Gracie Jacob, St. John Fisher |
Kelly Greapentrog, St. John Fisher |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
McKenzie Hart, Nazareth |
Lindsay Gilbert, St. John Fisher |
Kelly Greapentrog, St. John Fisher |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
| 2018 |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
Elizabeth Chu, Stevens |
Alea Steigerwald, St. John Fisher |
Annie McShea,
Stevens |
Kelsey Milligan, Nazareth |
| 2017 |
Casey King, Stevens
Anna Marcy, SJFC |
Sydni Horner, Stevens |
Maria Sorriento, Hartwick
Rebecca Hay, St. John Fisher |
Annie McShea, Stevens |
Sara Hain, Stevens |
| 2016 |
Joelle Goldstein, Ithaca |
Sydni Horner, Stevens |
Casey King, Stevens
Amber Smith, Alfred |
Glenn DeHaven,
Stevens |
Joelle Goldstein, Ithaca |
| 2015 |
Mary Tobin, Stevens |
Sydni Horner, Stevens |
Katie Evans, Ithaca |
Glenn DeHaven,
Stevens |
Kayla Gromen, Ithaca |
| 2014 |
Maria Allocco, Nazareth |
Laurel Wroblicky, Houghton |
Syndi Horner, Stevens |
Glenn DeHaven,
Stevens |
Brianna Evans, Stevens |
| 2013 |
Samantha Gates, Stevens |
Kirsten Salmins, Stevens |
Mary Tobins, Stevens |
Glenn DeHaven, Stevens |
Maria Allocco, Nazareth |
| 2012 |
Maggie Kowalski, Stevens |
Brittany Crocetti, Nazareth |
Carly Garone, Ithaca |
Cal Wickens, Nazareth |
Maria Allocco, Nazareth |
| 2011 |
Sasha Zavadska, Elmira |
Kelsey Osborne, St. John Fisher |
Maria Allocco, Nazareth |
Cal Wickens, Nazareth |
Maria Allocco, Nazareth |
| 2010 |
Sasha Zavadska, Elmira |
Julia Reilly, Stevens |
Taryn Rumsey, Elmira |
Janet Donovan, Ithaca |
|
| 2009 |
Sarah Byrne, Stevens |
Mallory Clary, Nazareth |
Maggie Kowalski, Stevens |
JJ O'Connell, Stevens |
|
| 2008 |
Melanie Volk, Stevens |
Mallory Clary, Nazareth |
Audrey Zimmerman, Nazareth |
JJ O'Connell, Stevens |
|
| 2007 |
Melissa Rhode, Stevens |
Jenna Waldron, St. John Fisher |
Christina Evans, Hartwick |
JJ O'Connell, Stevens |
|
| 2006 |
Amanda Hubbard, Ithaca |
Mary Schaefer, Ithaca |
Corinna Doctor, Ithaca |
Cal Wickens, Nazareth |
|
|
Player of the Year |
Rookie |
Coach |
|
| 2005 |
LeKeisha Perez, RIT |
Alyssa Ziobrowski, St. John Fisher |
Jim Chan, St. John Fisher |
|
| 2004 |
Tricia Jones, Nazareth |
Katie Hause, Ithaca |
Janet Donovan, Ithaca |
|
| 2003 |
Tricia Jones, Nazareth |
Colleen Kiser, St. John Fisher |
Roger Worsley, RIT |
|
| 2002 |
Christa Downey, Nazareth |
Chris Anabel, RIT |
Linda Downey, Nazareth |
|
| 2001 |
Christa Downey, Nazareth |
Sarah Ballard, RIT
Lori Wilkinson, St. John Fisher |
Linda Downey, Nazareth |
|
| 2000 |
Leah Malliris, Elmira |
|
Rhonda Faunce, Elmira |
|