| Year |
Track |
Field |
Rookie |
Coach/Coaching Staff of the Year |
| 2024 |
Cade Eells, Nazareth |
Justin Swavely, Utica |
Bennett Melita, Utica |
Utica University |
| 2023 |
Cade Eells, Nazareth |
Justin Swavely, Utica |
TyJon Billinger, Utica |
Nazareth University |
| 2022 |
Nathan Bowers, Nazareth |
Kyle Rollins, St. John Fisher |
John Coddington, Russell Sage
Benjamin Lewis, Nazareth |
Utica University |
| 2021 |
Grant Stokoe, St. John Fisher |
Kyle Rollins, St. John Fisher |
Daijon Richards, Utica |
St. John Fisher College |
| 2020* |
|
|
|
|
| 2019 |
Eddie Mahana, St. John Fisher |
Kyle Rollins, St. John Fisher |
DeAndre Fyffe, Utica |
St. John Fisher College |
| 2018 |
Peter Girardi, St. John Fisher |
Mark VanMarter, St. John Fisher |
Kyle Rollins, St. John Fisher |
St. John Fisher College |
| 2017 |
Peter Girardi, St. John Fisher |
Seth Spicer, Alfred |
Eddie Mahana, St. John Fisher |
Utica College |
| 2016 |
Peter Girardi, St. John Fisher |
Luis Rivera, Nazareth College |
Keanu Heedrum, Utica College |
Utica College |
| 2015 |
Nicodemus Gambill, Utica |
Devin Cornelius, St. John Fisher |
Mark VanMarter, St. John Fisher |
St. John Fisher College |
| 2014 |
Sawyer Hitchcock, Ithaca
Shane Ruffing, Utica |
Sean Locker, Alfred
Devin Cornelius, St. John Fisher |
Rayshawn Scott, Utica |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2013 |
Jake Lafaver, Nazareth |
Alec Svoboda, Ithaca |
Sawyer Hitchcock, Ithaca |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2012 |
Joe Pruckno, Utica
Richard Scott, Alfred |
Jusan Hamilton, Ithaca |
Mason Mann, Ithaca |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2011 |
Matt Marion, RIT |
Michael Dempsey, RIT |
Breiten Balschmiter, Utica |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2010 |
Max Orenstein, Ithaca |
Michael Dempsey, RIT |
Chris Mastrosimone, Ithaca |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2009 |
Jeff Wetmore, Ithaca |
Corey Petermann, Ithaca |
Doug Koury, Ithaca |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2008 |
Nick Stenuf, Nazareth |
Stephen Burns, RIT |
Jeff Wetmore, Ithaca |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |
| 2007 |
Nick Stenuf, Nazareth |
Stephen Burns, RIT |
|
David Warth, RIT |
|
Athlete |
Rookie |
Coach |
| 2006 |
Nick Stenuf, Nazareth |
Drew Hodge, Ithaca |
David Warth, RIT |
| 2005 |
Jimmy Sorel, RIT |
Matt Bango, RIT |
Jim Nichols, Ithaca |