| Year |
Player |
Libero |
Rookie |
Coaching Staff |
| 2025 |
Owen Wickens, Nazareth |
Trace La Robardiere, St. John Fisher
Thomas McNulty, SUNY Poly |
Paten Buckwalter, Elmira |
Cal Wickens, St. John Fisher |
| 2024 |
Jake Baker, St. John Fisher
Owen Wickens, Nazareth |
Trace La Robardiere, St. John Fisher |
Sonepith Keoviengsamay, St. John Fisher |
Matt Cohen, St. John Fisher |
| 2023 |
Owen Wickens, Nazareth |
Seth Terzo, Nazareth |
Gabe La Robardiere, St. John Fisher |
Matt Cohen, St. John Fisher |
| 2022 |
Jake Baker, St. John Fisher
Owen Wickens, Nazareth |
David Cerqua, St. John Fisher |
Alberto Mauricio, Elmira
Josh Weaver, Nazareth |
Stephen England, St. John Fisher |
| 2020 |
Josh Bigford, St. John Fisher |
David Cerqua, St. John Fisher |
Tyler Anderson, Elmira |
Stephen England, St. John Fisher |
| 2019 |
David Lehman, Stevens |
|
Josh Bigford, St. John Fisher |
Stephen England, St. John Fisher |
| 2018 |
Thomas Burrell, Stevens |
David Cerqua, St. John Fisher |
Scott Sanders, Sage |
Patrick Dorwalski, Stevens |
|
|
|
|
|
*2021 awards were not awarded, as the Empire 8 had three teams compete, falling below the four-team threshold for league honors.