| D3 Baseball |
ABCA/Rawlings |
| Zach Eldred | First Team | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
Zach Eldred | First Team | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
| Anthony Lapine | Third Team | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
Anthony Lapine | Fourth Team | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
| Noah Campanelli | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
James Murphy | Fourth Team | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Patrick McGuire | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
Noah Campanelli | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Noah Campanelli | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
Patrick McGuire | Fourth Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Adam Zebrowski | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
Adam Zebrowski | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Justin Graham | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
Justin Graham | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Allen Murphy | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
Allen Murphy | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Emmett Dunn | Fourth Team | Ithaca | 2019 |
Nick Flemister | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
| Jayson Yano | Third Team | Stevens | 2016 |
Tim Locastro | First Team | Ithaca | 2013 |
| Jayson Yano | Second Team | Stevens | 2015 |
Pat Lemmo | First Team | Ithaca | 2013 |
| Nick Flemister | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
John Prendergast | Third Team | Ithaca | 2013 |
| John Prendergast | Third Team | Ithaca | 2014 |
Steve Karnyski | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Justin D'Amato | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
Justin D'Amato | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Pat Lemmo | First Team | Ithaca | 2013 |
Sean Osterman | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Tim Locastro | Second Team | Ithaca | 2013 |
Jeremy Peters | Second Team | Ithaca | 2006 |
| Justin D'Amato | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2013 |
Matt Fuller | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2006 |
| Steven Karnyski | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
Rob Raux | Third Team | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Justin D'Amato | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
Tom O'Connor | Second Team | Ithaca | 2004 |
| Pete McDaniel | Second Team | Ithaca | 2009 |
Ron Amato | Third Team | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Shane Wolf | First Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
Tony Farago | Third Team | Ithaca | 1999 |