| GCAA Ping |
| Corey Haas | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2015-16 |
| Corey Haas | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2014-15 |
| Chris Blyth | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2014-15 |
| Chris Blyth | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2013-14 |
| Thad Weir | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2013-14 |
| Ryan McGinnis | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2013-14 |
| Chris Blyth | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2012-13 |
| Joe Radulski | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2012-13 |
| Tyler McArdell | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2011-12 |
| Thad Weir | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2011-12 |
| Tyler McArdell | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2010-11 |
| Brandon Christo | Third Team | Elmira | 2008-09 |
| Mitch Mercer | Third Team | Susquehanna | 2008-09 |
| Scott Harris Jr. | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2006-07 |