| USTFCCCA |
| Jonathan Zavala | First Team | Mile | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
| Jacob Miller | First Team | 400-Meters | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Manuel Sepulveda | First Team | Triple Jump | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Manuel Sepulveda | Second Team | Long Jump | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Gabe Giannini | Second Team | Long Jump | SUNY Brockport | 2025 |
| Hunter Logan | Second Team | Shot Put | Utica | 2025 |
| Sam Belmont | Second Team | 4 x 400-Meter Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Jacob Miller | Second Team | 4 x 400-Meter Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Jacob Miller | Second Team | 4 x 400-Meter Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Arjun Ohja | Second Team | 4 x 400-Meter Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Kaleb Luton | 60-Meter Hurdles | Nazareth | 2024 |
| Sean Cochrane | High Jump | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Kyle Rollins | High Jump | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Kyle Rollins | Triple Jump | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Hunter Logan | Shot Put | Utica | 2022 |
| Eddie Mahana | 60-Meter Hurdles | St. John Fisher | 2020 |
| Kyle Rollins | High Jump | St. John Fisher | 2020 |
| Kyle Rollins | Triple Jump | St. John Fisher | 2020 |
| Eddie Mahana | 60m Hurdles | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Kyle Rollins | High Jump | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Keanu Heedram | Shot Put | Utica | 2019 |
| Ka'Sean Watlington | Triple Jump | Utica | 2019 |
| Seth Spicer | Heptathlon | Alfred | 2018 |
| Peter Girardi | 60m Hurdles | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Kyle Rollins | High Jump | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Mark VanMarter | Long Jump | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Alex Kainer | 200m | Stevens | 2018 |
| Seth Spicer | Heptathlon | Alfred | 2017 |
| Nicodemus Gambill | 60m | Utica | 2017 |
| Nicodemus Gambill | 200m | Utica | 2017 |
| Clarence Skipper | Triple Jump | Utica | 2017 |
| Andrew Brandt | High Jump | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Luis Rivera | Weight Throw | Nazareth | 2016 |
| Kyle Koehler | Shot Put | St. John Fisher | 2016 |
| Luis Rivera | Weight Throw | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Devin Cornelius | Heptathlon | St. John Fisher | 2015 |
| Joe Pruckno | 60m Hurdles | Utica | 2012 |
| Mike Dempsey | Pole Vault | RIT | 2011 |
| Mike Dempsey | Pole Vault | RIT | 2010 |