| USILA |
| Jack Cornell | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Jordan Leuze | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Brady Mason | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Quinn McKercher | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2025 |
| Timmy Salit | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Connor Mesh | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Joe Johnson | Honorable Mention | Russell Sage | 2025 |
| Josh Knapp | Honorable Mention | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Tyler Manning | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Jakob Denkenberger | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2025 |
| Matthew Kemmis | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Jack Cornell | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Quinn McKercher | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2024 |
| Quinn Conroy | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2024 |
| Jordan Leuze | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Connor Mesh | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Joe Johnson | Honorable Mention | Russell Sage | 2024 |
| Ben Hammond | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Kevin Matson | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2023 |
| Quinn McKercher | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2023 |
| Timmy Salit | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Sam Miller | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Connor Mesh | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Brian Jantz | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Jack Cornell | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Jack Mulvihill | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Joe Post | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Nicholas Miller | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Ian Evans | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Brett Randall | Third Team | Nazareth | 2022 |
| Kyle Rochester | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Matthew Jeffries | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Jordan Depetres | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Tucker O'Donnell | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Jonathan Roth | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2022 |
| Griffin Randall | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2022 |
| Scott Kimiecik | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2022 |
| Roger Panara | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Joe Post | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Ian Evans | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Jack Mulvihill | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Nicholas Miller | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Roger Panara | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Jeremy Jacob | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Tucker O'Donnell | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Jonathan Roth | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Max Bailey | Third Team | Stevens | 2019 |
| Dean Peluso | Third Team | Stevens | 2019 |
| Nicholas Miller | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Ryan Gebhardt | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2019 |
| Jack Muvihill | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Eric Radbourne | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2019 |
| Bubba Brennan | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2019 |
| Carson White | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2019 |
| Joe Post | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Max Bailey | Third Team | Stevens | 2018 |
| Jake Lynch | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2018 |
| Andrew Russo | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| John Boutureira | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Tommy Dawson | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Daniel Crotty | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Dallas Creamer | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Seth DeLisle | Second Team | Nazareth | 2017 |
| Winston Wenham | Third Team | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Jack Deragon | Third Team | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Max Bailey | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Tommy Dawson | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| John Januszkiewicz | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Jake Lynch | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2017 |
| Jack Shumway | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2017 |
| John Bouturiera | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Hunter Burdick | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2017 |
| Josh DellaPuca | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Luke Longo | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2017 |
| Chris Contino | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Jan Schoonen | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Eli Gobrecht | First Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Scott Sidnam | First Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Luke Wooters | Second Team | Nazareth | 2016 |
| Matthew Ferentini | Second Team | Stevens | 2016 |
| John Januszkiewicz | Third Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Mike Walker | Third Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Jake Cotton | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Troy Haefele | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2016 |
| Jake Lynch | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2016 |
| Andrew Schrutchfield | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Jack Shumway | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Matt O'Neill | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2016 |
| Jan Schoonen | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Luke Longo | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2016 |
| Tim Fair | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Winston Wenham | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Drew Simoneau | First Team | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Luke Wooters | Second Team | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Eli Gobrecht | Second Team | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Jerry Chasteen | Third Team | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Troy Haefele | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Jack Shumway | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Michael Maroon | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2015 |
| Luke Longo | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2015 |
| Scott Sidnam | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Drew Simoneau | Third Team | Nazareth | 2014 |
| Pat Slawta | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2014 |
| Jake Long | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2014 |
| David Haseley | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
| Michael Blood | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
| Eli Gobrecht | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2014 |
| Nicolas Philipi | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Richard Dupras | Third Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Jeff Wester | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2013 |
| Luke Wooters | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Collin Clark | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Harrison Dorne | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2013 |
| Jake Long | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2013 |
| Chris Peterson | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Drew Simoneau | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Michael Blood | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2013 |
| Jake Spadoni | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2013 |
| Adam Wacenske | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2013 |
| Richard Dupras | First Team | Stevens | 2012 |
| Mike Krajacic | Third Team | Utica | 2012 |
| Matt Marks | Third Team | Stevens | 2012 |
| CJ Estes | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2012 |
| Connor Henderson | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Alex Hofrichter | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| Mitchell Ritchie | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Kyle Denhoff | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Harrison Dorne | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| Nicolas Philipi | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| Mitchell Bailey | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Michael Steinhauser | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| MJ Kiekebelt | First Team | RIT | 2011 |
| Jordan Macintosh | Second Team | RIT | 2011 |
| Kelso Davis | Third Team | RIT | 2011 |
| Brandon Faubert | Third Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Zach McHugh | Third Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Joe Jacobs-Ferderbar | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2011 |
| Tyler Russell | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2011 |
| Scott Castle | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2011 |
| Chris Laurita | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2011 |
| Egon Rassow | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2011 |
| Mitchell Frey | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2011 |
| Brian Orr | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2011 |
| Bob Tonnessen | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2011 |
| Mark DeCirce | Third Team | Nazareth | 2010 |
| MJ Kiekebelt | Third Team | RIT | 2010 |
| Dan Macrae | Third Team | RIT | 2010 |
| Sean Gilles | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2010 |
| Joe Jacobs-Ferderbar | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Scott Castle | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Kyle Denhoff | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2010 |
| Jordan Macintosh | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2010 |
| Kyle Brown | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Zach McHugh | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2010 |
| David Decker | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2010 |
| David Gal | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2010 |
| Neth Wiedemann | First Team | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Matt Keating | Second Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| David Wood | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2009 |
| David Decker | Second Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| JR Oreskovich | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2009 |
| Alec Siefert | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Scott Castle | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2009 |
| Nic Heckman | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Daniel Macrae | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2009 |
| Matt Nelligan | First Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Brandon Rose | First Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Craig Lepiane | Second Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Neth Weidemann | Second Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Aaron Civalier | Third Team | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Jacob Tuller | Third Team | RIT | 2008 |
| Logan Bobzein | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Dan Rago | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2008 |
| Andrew Ruocco | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2008 |
| Philip Davenport | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2008 |
| David Decker | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2008 |
| Ryan Hotaling | First Team | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Chad Amidon | First Team | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Dennis Butler | Second Team | Ithaca | 2007 |
| JR Oreskovich | Third Team | Stevens | 2007 |
| Matt Nellingan | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Eric Pritchard | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2007 |
| Scott Farress | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2007 |
| Andrew Ruocco | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2007 |
| Mark Bielicky | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Craig Lepiane | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Brandon Rose | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Josh Smith | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Neth Weidemann | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Ryan Conley | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Jacob Tuller | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2007 |
| David Thering | First Team | RIT | 2006 |
| Ryan Hotaling | Third Team | Nazareth | 2006 |
| Eric Pritchard | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2006 |
| Zachary Bednarz | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2006 |
| Jeff Mangini | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2006 |
| Jacob Tuller | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2006 |
| Dennis Butler | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2006 |
| Ryan Hotaling | First Team | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Matt Casey | First Team | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Bryan Adams | Second Team | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Chris Cimini | Second Team | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Mike Maher | Third Team | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Bryan Coon | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2005 |
| David Thering | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2005 |
| Brian Weil | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Gordon Quonce | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Dennis Butler | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Alex Civalier | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Zach Bednarz | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2005 |
| Mike Debrossy | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2005 |
| Francis Donald | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2005 |
| Joshua Molinari | Second Team | RIT | 2004 |
| Bryan Adams | Third Team | Nazareth | 2004 |
| Brandon Brown | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2004 |
| David Vail | Honorable Mention | Alfred | 2004 |
| Justin Wahl | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2004 |
| Brian Weil | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2004 |
| Christopher Copeland | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2004 |
| Brian Navarra | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2004 |
| TJ Rogers | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2004 |
| Mike Maher | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2004 |
| Chris Cimini | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2004 |
| Jonathan Manley | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2004 |
| Tim Riley | Third Team | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Bryan Coon | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2003 |
| Nick Mayer | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Dennis Juleff | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Ryan Maloney | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2003 |
| Matt Kent | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2003 |
| Jim Quackenbush | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2003 |
| Ryan Martin | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Ross Pino | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2003 |
| Christopher Vallone | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2003 |
| Dennis Juleff | First Team | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Jarod Koopman | Third Team | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Craig Sleeman | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Ryan Hoffmeister | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2002 |
| PJ Rosencrans | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Daniel Tuschong | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2002 |
| Tim Riley | Second Team | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Kevin Flannagan | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Brant Kasschau | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2002 |
| Ethan Sleeman | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Ryan Martin | Third Team | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Eric Goodberlet | First | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Mark Sovie | First Team | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Dennis Juleff | Second Team | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Ethan Sleeman | Second Team | Nazareth | 2001 |
| PJ Rosencrans | Third Team | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Al Terilli | Third Team | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Jim Cianfrocca | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Jarod Koopman | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Dan Duschong | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2001 |
| Tim Riley | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Rob Carroll | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Jake Coon | First Team | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Eric Goodberlet | Second Team | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Mark Sovie | Second Team | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Ryan Trombley | Second Team | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Craig Whipple | Third Team | RIT | 2000 |
| Jeff Keys | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Dennis Juleff | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Clay Westbrook | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2000 |
| Chris Corcoran | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Al Terilli | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2000 |
| PJ Rosencrans | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Kevin Leonard | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Vincent DeGregori | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2000 |
| Adam Platzer | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2000 |
| Bret Jacobsen | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2000 |
| Ben Hunt | First Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Joe Tuschong | First Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Kevin Langdale | Second Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Marc Heagney | Third Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Eric Carlsen | Third Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Jake Coon | Third Team | Nazareth | 1999 |
| Adam Platzer | Third Team | RIT | 1999 |
| Eric Goodberlet | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 1999 |
| Eric MacCaull | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 1999 |
| Billy Serino | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 1999 |
| Chris Nadelen | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 1999 |
| John Nevin | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 1999 |
| Vin DeGregorio | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 1999 |
| Ryan Trombley | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 1999 |