| United Soccer Coaches |
D3 Soccer |
| Christian Burkhart | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
Colin Phillips | Third Team | Stevens | 2015 |
| Ander Castillo | Second Team | Medaille | 2022 |
Zeke Hemme | Second Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Jesse Toth | Third Team | Houghton | 2016 |
Paul Killian | First Team | Stevens | 2012 |
| Colin Phillips | Third Team | Stevens | 2015 |
Leonard Casas | Second Team | Stevens | 2012 |
|
Zach Adler | First Team | Stevens | 2011 |
|
Nolan Sanberg | First Team | Stevens | 2010 |
|
Zach Carr | First Team | Stevens | 2010 |