| NFHCA |
| Katrina Clare | Second Team | SUNY Geneseo | 2024 |
| Hailey Roethel | Third Team | SUNY Geneseo | 2024 |
| Amy Stevens | Second Team | Russell Sage | 2023 |
| Sydney Gagnon | Second Team | Hartwick | 2022 |
| Bre Socker | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Lindsay Scott | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Bre Socker | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Lauren Fazio | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Emily Markarian | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2017 |
| Emily Markarian | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2016 |
| Hannah Mackey | First Team | Utica | 2014 |
| Alaina Stojkovski | Third Team | Utica | 2014 |
| Marguerite Chavez | Second Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Hannah Mackey | Third Team | Utica | 2013 |
| Louise Steele-Norton | First Team | Utica | 2012 |
| Marguerite Chavez | Second Team | Stevens | 2012 |
| Mallory Swanson | Third Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Jennifer Marabella | Second Team | Washington & Jefferson | 2010 |
| Kara Borzillo | Second Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| Hillary Paul | Second Team | Stevens | 2008 |
| Allison Shields | Third Team | Stevens | 2008 |
| Stephanie Smith | Second Team | Stevens | 2007 |
| Shannon Rohacek | Third Team | Utica | 2005 |
| Carla Behe | Second | Utica | 2004 |