| NFCA |
| Jessica Remm | Second Team | Alfred | 2025 |
| Kaijah Alexander | Third Team | Nazareth | 2025 |
| Emily McManus | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Jennifer Rodriguez | Third Team | Utica | 2024 |
| Arianna Papas | Third Team | Russell Sage | 2023 |
| Jessica Wilcox | Second Team | Alfred | 2021 |
| Ashley Lugo | Second Team | Alfred | 2021 |
| Allison O'Toole | Second Team | Alfred | 2021 |
| Emily Trotman | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Lindsey Thayer | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Lindsey Thayer | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2017 |
| Katie Mazierski | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2017 |
| Liz Thompson | Second Team | Alfred | 2017 |
| Lindsey Thayer | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2016 |
| Liz Thompson | Second Team | Alfred | 2015 |
| Alison Wickwire | Second Team | Alfred | 2015 |
| Lindsey Thayer | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2015 |
| Megan Matan | Third Team | Utica | 2014 |
| Sarah Fordyce | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2013 |
| Sydney Folk | Third Team | Ithaca | 2012 |
| Nicole Hedrick | Second Team | Alfred | 2010 |
| Erica Cutspec | Third Team | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Hannah Shalett | First Team | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Nicole Cade | First Team | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Kaitlyn Dulac | Third Team | Ithaca | 2006 |
| Kristin Furdon | First Team | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Amanda Kent | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2002 |
| Molly Schneible | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2002 |
| Laura Remia | First Team | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Kristin Furdon | First Team | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Robin Bimson | Second Team | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Laura Remia | Second Team | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Danniel Guccia | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2000 |
| Laura Remia | Second Team | Ithaca | 1999 |
| Danniel Guccia | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 1999 |
| Cheryl Wah | Second Team | Ithaca | 1999 |