| IWLCA |
| Sydney Carpenter | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Maddie Lowney | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Hanna Kumpf | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2025 |
| Sydney Carpenter | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Sydney Carpenter | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Shannon Foster | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Emma Parry | Third Team | Nazareth | 2022 |
| Sydney DeGirolamo | First Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Logan Chase | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Molly Tice | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Kyra Bednarski | First Team | Stevens | 2018 |
| Ally Runyon | First Team | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Molly Long | Third Team | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Erika Wilcox | Second Team | Stevens | 2016 |
| Erika Wilcox | Second Team | Stevens | 2015 |
| Ally Runyon | Third Team | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Taylor Hughes | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2014 |
| Melissa Leonhard | Second Team | St. John Fisher | 2013 |
| Spencer Waybright | Second Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Ashley Carey | Third Team | Stevens | 2012 |
| Melissa Leonhard | Third Team | St. John Fisher | 2012 |
| Kate Cox | Second Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Christine Smith | Second Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Shelby Vakiener | Second Team | RIT | 2011 |
| Alyssa Pigott | First Team | Stevens | 2010 |
| Kate Cox | Second Team | Stevens | 2010 |
| Christine Smith | Second Team | Stevens | 2010 |
| Kate Cox | Second Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| Kelsey Evans | Second Team | RIT | 2009 |
| Alyssa Pigott | Second Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| Christine Smith | Third Team | Stevens | 2009 |
| Brooke AnDrew | Second Team | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Becky Karver | Second Team | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Brooke AnDrew | Third Team | Ithaca | 2000 |
| Maya Lambiase | Third Team | Nazareth | 2000 |
| Sue Ketcham | Second Team | Hartwick | 1999 |
| Mollie Wynia | Third Team | Hartwick | 1999 |