| CSCAA |
| Alise Hale | First Team | 200-Yard Butterfly | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Alise Hale | Second Team | 100-Yard Butterfly | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Alex Sotek | Second Team | 50-Yard Freestyle | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Nina Chicatelli | Second Team | 200-Yard Medley Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Alise Hale | Second Team | 200-Yard Medley Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Alex Sotek | Second Team | 200-Yard Medley Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Emily Thomas | Second Team | 200-Yard Medley Relay | SUNY Geneseo | 2025 |
| Alexa Rizzo | First Team | 1-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2024 |
| Taylor Robey | 50-Yard Freestlyle | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Taylor Robey | 100-Yard Freestyle | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Allie Norwood | 1-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Allie Norwood | 3-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Elizabeth Tripp | 1-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Elizabeth Tripp | 3-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Taylor Woltz | 1-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Taylor Woltz | 3-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2021 |
| Allie Norwood | 1-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2020 |
| Allie Norwood | 3-Meter Diving | Nazareth | 2020 |
| Taylor Robey | 50-Yard Freestyle | Nazareth | 2020 |
| Grace Ayer | 200 IM | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Grace Ayer | 200 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Grace Ayer | 400 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Grace Ayer | 100 Breast | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Lake Duffy | 200 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Lake Duffy | 400 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Lake Duffy | 50 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Nickie Griesemer | 3m Diving | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Nickie Griesemer | 1m Diving | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Jackie Pecze | 200 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Jackie Pecze | 400 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Sam Reilly | 200 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Sam Reilly | 400 Medley Relay | Ithaca | 2017 |
| Anna Belson | First Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Katie Helly | Second Team | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Danielle Caruso | Second Team | Stevens | 2016 |
| Courtney Jones | Second Team | Stevens | 2016 |
| Sarah Jurczyk | Second Team | Stevens | 2016 |
| Brittany Geyer | First Team | Stevens | 2015 |
| Nickie Griesemer | First Team | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Anna Belson | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Sarah Jurczyk | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2015 |
| Brittany Geyer | First Team | Stevens | 2014 |
| Nickie Griesemer | First Team | Ithaca | 2014 |
| Grace Ayer | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2014 |
| Marissa Douglas | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Brittany Geyer | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| April Lawson | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Louise Moores | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Carissa Risucci | First Team | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Sharon Rooker | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Jennifer Rutledge | First Team | Stevens | 2013 |
| Elizabeth Heinbach | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2013 |
| Carly Jones | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2013 |
| Nicole Miller | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2013 |
| Jade Woodend | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2013 |
| Korie Fackler | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2012 |
| Korie Fackler | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2012 |
| Carly Jones | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2012 |
| Carissa Risucci | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2012 |
| Carissa Risucci | 200 Breast | Nazareth | 2012 |
| Brittany Geyer | 100 Breat | Stevens | 2012 |
| Brittany Geyer | 200 Breast | Stevens | 2012 |
| Brittany Geyer | 200 IM | Stevens | 2012 |
| Louise Moores | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| Louise Moores | 100 Back | Stevens | 2012 |
| Louise Moores | 100 Fly | Stevens | 2012 |
| Sian Pearson | 500 Freestyle | Stevens | 2012 |
| Sheila Rhoades | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2011 |
| Sheila Rhoades | 100 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2011 |
| Carissa Risucci | 200 Breast | Nazareth | 2011 |
| Laura Barito | 50 Freestyle | Stevens | 2011 |
| Laura Barito | 100 Freestyle | Stevens | 2011 |
| Louise Moores | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2011 |
| Amanda Nauman | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2011 |
| Sheila Rhoades | 50 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2010 |
| Sheila Rhoades | 100 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2010 |
| Sheila Rhoades | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2010 |
| Lindsey Buzard | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Carissa Risucci | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Carissa Risucci | 200 Breast | Nazareth | 2010 |
| Laura Barito | 50 Freestyle | Stevens | 2010 |
| Laura Barito | 100 Freestyle | Stevens | 2010 |
| Rebecca Blazak | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Lauren Botterbusch | 100 Breast | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Lauren Botterbusch | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Sheila Rhoades | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2009 |
| Caitlyn Burr | Honorable Mention | RIT | 2009 |
| Laura Barito | 40 Freestyle | Stevens | 2009 |
| Laura Barito | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2009 |
| Lauren Botterbusch | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2008 |
| Emily Lesher | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Emily Lesher | 200 IM | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Emily Lesher | 400 IM | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Emily Lesher | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Emily Lesher | 200 IM | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Emily Lesher | 400 IM | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Lorrie Brabender | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Lauren Botterbusch | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2006 |
| Aubrey Kirchoff | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2006 |
| Emily Lesher | 200 IM | Nazareth | 2006 |
| Emily Lesher | 400 IM | Nazareth | 2006 |
| Gayle Gregory | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2004 |
| Gayle Gregory | 100 Back | Hartwick | 2004 |
| Julie Landmann | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2004 |
| Megan Hughes | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2004 |
| Megan Hughes | 200 IM | Ithaca | 2004 |
| Gayle Gregory | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2003 |
| Julie Landmann | 100 Back | Hartwick | 2003 |
| Megan Hughes | 100 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Megan Hughes | 200 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Megan Hughes | 200 IM | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Kristen Shorette | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Team | 200 Free Relay Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Team | 400 Free Relay | Ithaca | 2003 |
| Cheryl Roubian | 100 Back | Nazareth | 2003 |
| Sara Thompson | 100 Back | Alfred | 2002 |
| Julie Landmann | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2002 |
| Danielle Moreau | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2002 |
| Megan Hughes | 100 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Megan Hughes | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Kristen Shorette | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Team | 400 Free Relay Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Team | 800 Free Relay | Ithaca | 2002 |
| Cheryl Roubian | 100 Back | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Cheryl Roubian | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2002 |
| Julie Meirs | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2001 |
| Megan Hughes | Honorable Mention | Ithaca| 2001 |
| Megan Hughes | 200 Freestyle | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Megan Hughes | 200 IM | Ithaca | 2001 |
| Cheryl Roubian | 100 Back | Nazareth | 2001 |
| Cheryl Roubian | Honorable Mention | 2001 |
| Jenn Souder | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2000 |