| AVCA |
| Lydia Fraser | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Tessa Grover | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2024 |
| Ana Gutman | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2024 |
| Braelyn Hornick | Honorable Mention | Hartwick | 2024 |
| Tessa Grover | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2023 |
| Kaylene Noble | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2023 |
| Sydney French | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2022 |
| Alea Steigerwald | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2021 |
| Alea Steigerwald | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2019 |
| Elizabeth Chu | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Sara Hain | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2018 |
| Alea Steigerwald | Honorable Mention | St. John Fisher | 2018 |
| Julie Greco | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Casey King | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Shelby Stewart | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Joelle Golstein | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2016 |
| Sara Hain | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Sydni Horner | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Brianna Perez | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Shelby Stewart | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Mary Tobin | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2016 |
| Katie Evans | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Joelle Goldstein | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Kayla Gromen | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2015 |
| Sydni Horner | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2015 |
| Mary Tobin | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2015 |
| Maria Alloco | Second Team | Nazareth | 2014 |
| Madi Wickens | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2014 |
| Maria Alloco | Third Team | Nazareth | 2013 |
| Taryn Rumsey | Honorable Mention | Elmira | 2013 |
| Maria Alloco | Honorale Mention | Nazareth | 2012 |
| Aubrey Cooke | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2012 |
| Maggie Kowalska | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2012 |
| Maggie Kowalska | First Team | Stevens | 2011 |
| Brittany Raykoske | Honorable Mention | Elmira | 2011 |
| Sasha Zavadska | Honorable Mention | Elmira | 2011 |
| Maggie Kowalska | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2010 |
| Taryn Rumsey | Honorable Mention | Elmira | 2010 |
| Sarah Byrne | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2009 |
| Mallorie Clary | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2009 |
| Maggie Kowalska | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2009 |
| Alexandra Zavadska | Honorable Mention | Elmira | 2009 |
| Katelynn Reed | Third Team | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Mallorie Clary | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Kate Zwickl | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2008 |
| Sarah Byrne | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2008 |
| Melissa Rhode | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2008 |
| Melanie Volk | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2008 |
| Jessica Gardner | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2017 |
| Dawn Herring | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Amanda Hubbard | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2007 |
| Laura Persico | Honorable Mention | Nazareth | 2007 |
| Melissa Rhode | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Kate Zwickl | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2007 |
| Dawn Herring | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2006 |
| Amanda Hubbard | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2006 |
| Melissa Rhode | Honorable Mention | Stevens | 2006 |
| Andrea Blitz | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Jennifer Cramer | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2005 |
| Amanda Hubbard | Honorable Mention | Ithaca | 2005 |