Pierce was named the Empire 8 Swimmer of the Championship Meet for the second straight year at the 2024 Empire 8 and Allegheny Empire Championships, held at the Webster Aquatic Center. She won the 100-yard breaststroke in a time of 1:06.75 on Feb. 16 and took the 200-yard breaststroke on Feb. 17, hitting the wall first in an Allegheny Empire meet record time of 2:24.52. In addition, she was second in the 200-yard individual medley and helped Hartwick to second place finishes in the 400-yard medley relay events and 200- and 400-yard freestyle relay.