Cusack returned two punts for a career-high 65 yards and a touchdown on Saturday in Courage Bowl XXI against SUNY Brockport. He returned his second punt 46 yards for a touchdown early in the fourth quarter to trim the Cardinals' deficit to three points, 24-21. It was St. John Fisher's first punt return touchdown since Sept. 21, 2019, against TCNJ. TySean Sizer returned a punt 76 yards for a score in that game. Cusack also added seven receptions for 103 yards.