Wagner was named Most Outstanding Player of the 2019 Empire 8 Championship Tournament after making 15 saves and recording a pair of shutouts in leading Utica to a pair of 1-0 wins and its first E8 title. On Wednesday, Wagner made eight saves, as No. 4 seed Utica knocked off top-seed St. John Fisher in a semifinal match. Saturday, Wagner was equally as impressive, turning aside seven shots, as Utica defeated No. 2 Hartwick to claim the title. Wagner is now 11-5-1 with a 0.94 goals against average and an .881 save percentage with eight shutouts this season.