McCaslin scored the game-winning field goal on Saturday to lift Alfred to a 24-21 win over Hartwick. He finished the night with 10 points on three field goals and a PAT. His first field goal came from 35 yards out right at the horn before halftime cutting Hartwick’s lead to 21-10. He then opened up the second half scoring spree for AU with a 24-yard field goal, bringing the score to 21-13. After AU tied the game with a touchdown and a successful 2-point conversion, McCaslin would sound the horns with a 28-yard, game-winning field goal. On kickoffs, McCaslin had five kicks for 284 yards and two touchbacks.